Are Food Intolerance Tests Accurate?

Food intolerance is a growing concern among many individuals experiencing adverse reactions to certain foods. Symptoms can range from mild gut discomfort to more pronounced effects like joint or abdominal pain. As more people seek solutions, food intolerance testing has gained significant attention. But are food intolerance tests accurate, and how do they compare to scientifically validated methods like allergy testing or elimination diets?

Call 020 7126 7101 to speak to the DNA Dietitian team, find out more about the food intolerance test, and ask about the most common food intolerances.

Understanding food intolerance and food allergies

First, it’s important to differentiate between food intolerance and food allergies. A food allergy occurs when the immune system reacts to a particular food, producing IgE antibodies, which can cause life-threatening symptoms such as difficulty breathing or anaphylaxis. In contrast, food intolerance does not involve the immune system in the same way. Instead, it often affects the digestive system and may cause symptoms such as abdominal pain, bloating, or irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).

Common food intolerances include lactose intolerance, where individuals struggle to digest lactose in milk and dairy products, and gluten sensitivity, often mistaken for coeliac disease, an autoimmune condition triggered by gluten.

How do food intolerance tests work?

Several methods are marketed for diagnosing food intolerances, including:

• IgG Tests
• These tests measure IgG antibodies in the blood. The premise is that an increased presence of IgG for a specific food indicates intolerance. However, many experts in clinical immunology argue there is limited scientific evidence to support this claim. IgG presence often reflects exposure to a food, not an intolerance.
• Hydrogen Breath Test
• This test is primarily used to diagnose lactose or fructose intolerance. By measuring hydrogen levels after consuming a test food, it identifies issues with digesting particular sugars.
• Pulse Test and Applied Kinesiology
• These unproven diagnostic tests claim to detect food sensitivities by monitoring pulse changes or muscle strength when exposed to food. However, they lack a scientific basis and are not endorsed by medical professionals.
• Hair Analysis and Other Tests
• Some tests analyse a hair sample or use home tests to identify food triggers. These methods are widely criticised for their unreliability.

Although food intolerance testing isn’t considered concrete evidence, it provides a great level of insight into suspect food intolerances and which food may lead to an adverse reaction. In essence, an IgG test, followed by working with a knowledgeable dietitian could make all the difference for a symptom-free life, void of a restricted diet.

Click here to speak to Rachel Clarkson and book a consultation.

Why food intolerance tests may be inaccurate

Many intolerance tests, especially those relying on IgG tests, face scrutiny for their lack of scientific evidence. Key reasons include:

• Normal Immune Response: The presence of IgG antibodies to different foods is a normal response, indicating tolerance, not intolerance.
• False Positives: Intolerance tests often identify multiple foods as problematic, leading to unnecessarily restricted diets and potential nutritional deficiencies.
• Unvalidated Methods: Tests like applied kinesiology and hair analysis are based on pseudoscience.

Proven approaches to diagnosing food intolerances

The most reliable methods for identifying food intolerances involve a combination of methods. A good starting point is with medical history and symptom tracking. Consulting a medical professional is crucial for understanding symptoms and pinpointing potential food triggers. That knowledge can help with the elimination diet where all suspect foods are removed from the diet and added back gradually. By doing this, it is possible to identify a patient’s tolerance threshold for certain foods. This approach is particularly effective for identifying common food triggers like dairy products, cured meats, and ripened fruits. Other Tests, like the hydrogen breath test, can confirm specific intolerances, such as the inability to digest lactose.

When to seek help

If you experience severe or life-threatening symptoms like an allergic reaction, difficulty breathing, or widespread adverse reactions to foods, it’s critical to seek care at allergy clinics or consult an allergist. For milder gut symptoms or increased sensitivity to specific foods, working with a nutritionist or gastroenterologist can help avoid unnecessary dietary restrictions and maintain a balanced diet.

The sooner you can identify allergy symptoms, food sensitivities, such as gluten intolerance, and adverse reactions to certain foods or food groups, the better!

Are food intolerance tests accurate? While tests like IgG tests and hair analysis are popular, their accuracy is highly questionable due to the lack of a robust scientific basis. Proven methods such as elimination diets and specific blood tests, under the guidance of a medical professional, remain the gold standard for managing food intolerances and related conditions. If you’re considering food intolerance testing, ensure it aligns with evidence-based practices to avoid unnecessary stress, reduced quality of life, or inappropriate dietary restrictions.

CONTACT RACHEL CLARKSON’S TEAM

The Clinic

The DNA Dietitian
10 Harley Street
London
W1G 9PF